Rep. Brennan Praises PUCO Decision to Reduce Electric Bill Impact for Ohio Consumers, Calls for Oversight on Cleveland Rate Increase

COLUMBUS — State Rep. Sean Patrick Brennan (D-Parma) today praised a new decision by the Public Utility Commission of Ohio (PUCO) ordering First Energy’s utilities to reduce the financial impact of electricity distribution rate changes, calling the move an important step toward protecting Ohio consumers and improving affordability.

“This decision clearly reflects that Ohio families are facing real affordability challenges,” said Rep. Brennan. “I commend the PUCO for taking action to lessen the burden of rising utility costs and for ensuring appropriate oversight and accountability in how these expenses are recovered.”

The PUCO ordered Cleveland Illuminating Company, Ohio Edison, and Toledo Edison to spread approximately $245 million in deferred storm restoration expenses over 25 years rather than the previously authorized five-year period. The Commission also affirmed that the costs remain subject to further review and audit.

While Rep. Brennan supports the overall consumer relief, he expressed concern about the impact on Cleveland-area customers.

“While I’m encouraged by the overall consumer relief, the rate increase for customers of the Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company is concerning and must be closely monitored to ensure it is fully justified,” added Rep. Brennan. “Cleveland-area ratepayers deserve transparency and accountability, and we must make sure they are treated fairly.”

The ruling will result in an approximate $39.4 million reduction in annual revenues for the utilities compared to the amounts authorized in November 2025.

Under the order:

• Ohio Edison will reduce annual revenues by approximately $24.5 million;
• Toledo Edison will reduce annual revenues by approximately $29.5 million; and
• Cleveland Electric Illuminating Company will increase annual revenues by approximately $48.7 million, though the overall impact across the three utilities results in a net reduction.

Rep. Brennan also highlights the importance of continued scrutiny of utility rate structures. 

“Strong regulatory oversight is essential to ensure that utility companies operate transparently and that rate adjustments remain fair and justified,” concluded Rep. Brennan. “Ohioans deserve an energy system that balances reliability with affordability.” 

The PUCO directed the utilities to file updated tariffs by Feb. 24, 2026, with new rates scheduled to take effect March 1, 2026. 

Case Background

On May 31, 2024, FirstEnergy filed an application seeking to increase electric distribution rates that would have generated approximately $190.3 million in additional annual revenue across its Ohio service territories. The PUCO held public hearings in Akron, Cleveland, and Toledo in April 2025, followed by an evidentiary hearing in May 2025.

Rep. Brennan pledges to continue monitoring utility rate proceedings and advocating for policies that protect Ohio consumers from excessive cost increases.